Audited September 2026. Research date: September 17-18, 2026. Expanded Oct 16, 2026 from the school OPRA production.
Last updated: 2026-10-16
| Request | Sent | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Town OPRA, 34 items | 2026-09-18 | Due Oct 16, 2026 |
| School district OPRA, 30 items | 2026-09-18 | Received Oct 15, 2026. Tracking matrix reviewed: documents produced for 17 of 30 items, 2 partial (14, 15), 4 referred to online sources or access (21, 22, 25, 27); 3 denied (11, 29, 30), 3 no-records (20, 24, 28), 1 marked NA (7). Denials cite no legal basis in the matrix. 122 PDFs received, no native data exports; 7 files are image-only scans. Request kept open pending review. Full read completed Oct 16, 2026: 13 new schedules added; B-09 corrected to contras/refunds (not deposit records); 11 files remain UNEXTRACTED (contents await OCR). |
| Library OPRA | 2026-09-22 | Answered in full Sep 23, 2026. Four PDFs UNEXTRACTED (image-only scans); library figures in the audit are README-sourced. |
Every chart is drawn from this audit's own reconciliation schedules, the same CSVs linked under Documents. No chart adds a number that is not in the schedules.
The same ten-step process every time. The highlighted step is where this audit stands: published, with monitoring open.
Every record family the audit needed, and what happened to it. Missing means the record was not located, not that anyone did anything wrong.
PDFs of system reports received, not native exports.
Columnar PDF text does not foot cleanly; no totals stated.
Unresolved for a third audit cycle.
CAP received Oct 15, 2026; FY2026 audit must test it.
Denied as confidential.
Agency response: none.
Agency states it does not maintain one.
Agency states it does not maintain one.
Received in the school production.
Received in the school production.
Received as image-only scans; contents await OCR.
Horizon renewal rates and Ch. 44 actuals tabulated; enrollment-by-tier decomposition still missing.
C-12 FY26 and FY27 report totals foot; itemized in capital-pos.csv.
Advertised/proposed detail, 96 pp; not the adopted UFB.
7 school files and 4 library files await OCR.
Excerpt received but extraction is garbled; no figures quoted.
Each card is a summary. The full reasoning, evidence, and caveats live in the documents below.
Unresolved for a third audit cycle. Corrective action plan adopted July 20, 2026; no implementation evidence through Sept 21, 2026.
Source: Full report
Corrective action plan received Oct 15, 2026, implementation date Dec 31, 2025. Implementation still to be verified by the FY2026 audit.
Source: Monitoring plan (42 items, W-1 to W-41)
Difference between municipal BAN appropriation and documented retirement. An open question, not savings.
Source: Full report
Matched capital outlay exactly. A presentation-classification problem, not missing money.
Source: Full report
None substantiated as of Sept 18, 2026.
Source: Full report
The $5,733 is the Assessment for Debt Service on SDA Funding, not unitemized. Watch item W-14 closed Oct 16, 2026.
Source: Full report section 9
The CAP claims implementation by Dec 31, 2025 and was attested Jan 5, 2026. The FY2026 audit tests whether the fixes worked.
Everything above is a visual summary. What follows is the verbatim audit text: the executive summary, with the full report, methods, monitoring plan, records requests, and records pages linked under Documents.
Independent, evidence-based review of the Town of Boonton (municipality) and the Town of Boonton School District, Morris County, New Jersey — NOT Boonton Township. Research date: September 17–18, 2026. School fiscal year: July 1–June 30. Municipal calendar year: January 1–December 31.
What this is. A public-records financial review — not a certified audit, not a forensic examination, and not an investigation designed to prove wrongdoing. Every Boonton-specific figure inherited from an earlier research session was treated as an unverified lead and independently re-checked against original documents. Findings are labeled by confidence; open questions are kept separate from facts. Full detail, citations, and reconciliation schedules are infull-report.mdandschedules/.
The Oct 15, 2026 school OPRA production (122 PDFs plus a tracking file) and the Sep 23, 2026 library production (4 PDFs) are integrated throughout this summary and the full report, with historical comparisons where the new data extends a series. Eleven files are image-only scans whose contents await OCR. Full file list: public records page. Changes to this audit are recorded in changelog.json.
School district (FY2026–27 FINAL adopted budget, 4/27/2026 — supersedes the advertised version). General Fund $38,629,369 (NJDOE UFB shows $38,629,370 — $1 rounding difference), +$231,571 (+0.6%) vs. the advertised $38,397,799. Documented causes in the adoption resolution: Energy/Natural Gas +$25,785, Energy/Electricity +$25,786, Construction Services +$180,000 (flooring upgrades); the resolution also includes a $984,178 adjustment for increased health-care costs — new evidence partially explaining the benefits increase. All-funds adopted expenditures $43,978,501 (GF $38,629,369 + Special Revenue $3,923,632 + Debt Service $1,425,500); total tax levy $25,616,067 (GF $24,604,443 + debt service $1,011,624). Confidence: high (adopted document + UFB).
Adopted detail confirmed by the account totals (A-03, run 10/13/2026). Fund 10 (charter) $145,468.00; Fund 11 adjusted $37,837,279.96 (original $37,814,375.64, transfers $22,904.32); Fund 12 adjusted $716,291.35 (original $669,525.00, transfers $46,766.35); Fund 20 adjusted $3,883,220.00 (original $3,936,997.08); Fund 40 debt service $1,425,500.00 (interest $390,500.00 + principal $1,035,000.00). General Fund original: $145,468.00 + $37,814,375.64 + $669,525.00 = $38,629,368.64, rounding to the adopted $38,629,369 ($0.36 rounding). Fund 12 original $669,525.00 = Construction Services $663,792.00 + Assessment for Debt Service on SDA Funding $5,733.00; Equipment $0.00. Special Revenue discrepancy flagged, not hidden: A-03 Fund 20 original $3,936,997.08 vs. C-13 proposed $3,981,998 vs. UFB adopted $3,923,632. Do not reconcile Special Revenue across sources without further records.
Advertised budget detail (C-13, 96 pp, generated July 24, 2026; proposed, not the adopted UFB). General Fund revenues: Local Tax Levy $24,604,443 (up $1,447,320, +6.25% vs. revised 2025-26 $23,157,123); Tuition from Other LEAs $6,205,885 (up $132,032, +2.17%); Total Local Sources $30,940,328; State Sources $7,266,247 (Equalization Aid $4,211,785, Special-Ed Categorical $1,784,849, Extraordinary Aid $800,000, Transportation Aid $132,377, Security Aid $337,236); Federal Medicaid $57,064; Budgeted Fund Balance $356,939; Withdraw from Capital Reserve $8,792; Total Operating Budget $38,629,370. Total Revenues/Sources (all funds) $44,036,868. Adequacy: District Adequacy Budget $27,012,255; Total Budgeted Adequacy Spending $28,816,228; Excess $1,803,973. The district's stated explanation for exceeding adequacy: "Healthcare premiums rose by 26.5% in 25-26 and are anticipated to rise by 15.5% in 26-27." That is the district's stated explanation, not an independently verified premium history. Per-pupil (Advertised Per Pupil Cost Calculations): Total Budgetary Comparative Per Pupil Cost: Proposed 2026-27 $23,071; Revised 2025-26 $22,616; Original 2025-26 $21,340; Actual 2024-25 $21,246; Actual 2023-24 $20,298. Confidence: high on the figures as printed in C-13.
Municipality (CY2026 adopted budget). Total $17,769,364, +6.24% (+$1,042,926) vs. the adopted 2025 budget ($16,726,438). Correction history: the review first stated +6.01% vs. $16,761,438 (the budget presentation's 2025 comparative column — not an adopted basis); a revision pass then "corrected" this to +3.41% vs. $17,182,605 — but $17,182,605 was the 2024 adopted total, misassigned by a year-inconsistent column defect in the town's budget workbooks — prior-year figures entered in the first data column on the revenue sheets of the 2024–2026 budgets (but not 2021's or 2023's, which follow their headings), opposite the printed headings — documented as an audit contribution in full-report.md §6.3). The 2025 adopted total is $16,726,438. Categories: salaries & wages $6,024,560; pensions/statutory $1,426,694; insurance incl. employee coverage $2,300,200; other operating $4,800,568; debt service $1,295,146 (adopted; the budget advertisement showed $1,274,702 = $920,000 principal + $354,702 interest); reserve for uncollected taxes $1,500,000 (a non-cash appropriation — not spendable money); capital improvement $200,000; grants $242,640. Confidence: high (recomputed exactly).
Property-tax allocation (CY2025 actual, from the town's 2026 budget — verified). Of each tax dollar: school district 62.31%, municipal purposes 26.06%, Morris County 9.95%, municipal library 1.41%, county open space 0.27%. The town keeps only the 26.06% municipal slice; the rest is collected as agent and remitted in full (school and county at 100% by law). Separately: property taxes are 62.35% of school General Fund revenue — a different ratio answering a different question. Illustrative $10,000 bill: $6,231 / $2,606 / $995 / $141 / $27 — illustrative only, not any resident's actual bill. Confidence: high on the shares; the Morris Plains 51.51% comparison is now verified (see §5 benchmarks).
| Finding | Status |
|---|---|
| Municipal fixed assets — no updated inventory, 3rd consecutive year (2025-001, significant deficiency) | Open. CAP adopted 7/20/2026 (Res. 26-207); no implementation evidence through 9/21/2026 (checked 7/20 and 8/17 minutes; 9/8 and 9/21 agendas). |
| Library hourly timesheets lacking director approval (2025 management recommendation) | Not verifiable from available records. June 2026 auditor commentary (Lerch Vinci and Bliss): the Treasurer AND Director must sign payment vouchers above $1,000; the Director must sign approval for hourly-employee payroll (already begun); capital reserve transfers need minute approval. |
| School FY2025: unemployment-claim documentation/timeliness (2025-01); revenue/receivable accuracy (2025-02); charter-payment schedule (2025-03); John Hill deposit timeliness (2025-04) | CAP received Oct 15, 2026 (board meeting 1/5/2026, attested by Superintendent Valle and BA Gardberg; implementation date 12/31/2025 for all four; owners: BA + Payroll Coordinator for 2025-01, BA + Assistant to the BA for 2025-02, BA + AP Coordinator for 2025-03, BA + School Secretary for 2025-04). New evidence: NJ927 confirmations (Q3 2025–Q2 2026) show GIT Balance Due $0.00 each quarter and UI/WF balances due $1,117.65 / $1,679.74 / $8,574.90 / $0.00; four FY26 Unity charter checks total $119,983.00 (the NJDOE schedule total) but the actual payment dates do not match the NJDOE monthly scheduled dates; no LEAD payment record was found in the produced records searched; the B-09 file is contras/refunds, not deposit records (JHS activity total ($68,903.53); PreK ($2,384.00)). Implementation pending FY2026 audit. Dollar amounts for 2025-01's interest/penalties are not stated anywhere. (Separate product: the ACFR's K-6 single-audit schedule, same 10/16/2025 report, shows zero financial-statement, federal, and state findings — low-risk auditee.) |
| School FY2024: treasurer's bond, payroll-deduction ledger, PO classification, board fund certification | Corrected with evidence (per FY2025 auditor follow-up; bond raised $250,000 → $267,000). |
No auditor reported a material weakness for either entity. The municipal audit opinion is qualified only as to the unaudited General Fixed Assets Account Group ($25,202,385) and unaudited LOSAP trust activity — not the Current Fund, utilities, or other funds. None of the findings reviewed constitutes evidence of missing money.
The 24 options in schedules/improvement-options.csv separate what is control hygiene (payment-deadline ownership, documentation retention, deposit rules, PO cleanup, timesheet approvals, public corrective-action tracking — mostly low cost, recurring benefit) from what needs evidence first (benefits and insurance decompositions, ESIP feasibility, shared-service inventory). No dollar savings are estimated where the records don't support one — most options are marked "not quantifiable from public records," which is itself the finding: the cost drivers cannot be managed until they are measured. The highest-priority asks are records, not cuts:
A 170-row public-records contracts register (schedules/contracts-register.csv) now supports a real procurement screen: no finding of favoritism, bid-splitting, or wrongdoing — competitively bid capital work (up to 14 bidders), a stable professional-services roster lawfully exempt from bidding, and two no-bid paths handled statutorily. Open procurement leads: the solid-waste award (Res. 23-271) with vendor/amount unverified; no bid tabs, proposals, or executed contracts posted publicly; BED certifications seen only for 2026. Vendor-payment registers FY24–FY27 and PO journals FY25–FY27 were received Oct 15, 2026 as PDFs of system reports (D-16, 695 pp; D-17, 236 pp), so the "no vendor-payment data obtainable" limitation is lifted. The columnar PDF text does not foot to a reliable grand total, so no duplicate-payment or PO-validity screen was run; per-vendor block examples that foot internally are tabulated in schedules/vendor-examples.csv (Horizon FY26 $7,198,254.01; Delta Dental FY26 $250,656.98; ESC FY26 $1,108,179.32; Depository Trust FY26 $1,425,300.00; Weatherproofing Technologies FY26 $884,751.64; Unity FY26 $119,983.00; Waste Management FY26 $33,775.94; Lerch Vinci Higgins FY26 $35,500.00; Celebrate the Children FY26 $668,564.00; Pomptonian FY26 $630,000.00 orders, $623,262.26 checks). D-17 report totals foot internally (Payments plus Open equals Amount): FY25 $52,995,899.77 / $52,831,796.82 / $164,102.95; FY26 $53,886,796.72 / $53,806,204.17 / $80,592.55; FY27 YTD $38,242,782.18 / $10,733,413.20 / $27,509,368.98. D-17 totals are NOT vendor-payment totals and NOT comparable to the budget (they include payroll POs and contra/negative entries). D-19 Account Code Listing: 73 pp, 1,640 distinct account-code rows, no dollar figures; it maps account codes to descriptions and budget line numbers. An executable test plan plus expanded draft records requests are in records-requests.md (drafts only; nothing was submitted). Board minutes 2023–2026 (81 individual files plus a compiled 2025 volume that duplicates the individual 2025 minutes) were mined for 20 additional contract-award rows; minutes record board affirmations of the Superintendent findings on numbered HIB complaints by building, but the minutes do NOT state whether each numbered complaint was substantiated, so no HIB counts are presented as substantiated incidents and no annual HIB total is stated. Donations are summarized without private donor family names. Public-comment questions and claims were not treated as findings. Personnel actions are summarized by category only. Employment contract terms (E-23): Gardberg (BA/Board Secretary), contract July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027: salary $180,522 plus longevity $2,100; health waiver lesser of 25% or $5,000; vacation 21 days, payout capped by 30 accumulated days; sick payout capped at $15,000; tuition reimbursement max $5,500; phone up to $125.00/month. Valle (Superintendent), contract July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2031: salary schedule $230,000 / $236,900 / $244,007 / $251,327 / $258,867; longevity $2,100/year; total annual salary including longevity $232,100 / $239,000 / $246,107 / $253,427 / $260,967; auto-renewal for 5 years expiring June 30, 2036 unless the Board notifies by July 1, 2030; sick payout max $15,000; health waiver $5,000 flat; tuition max $6,500/year; cell phone max $130.00/month; contract cost sheet totals $322,743 / $331,344 / $340,203 / $349,328 / $358,727. Principal contracts file is UNEXTRACTED; principal terms beyond salary and longevity are not stated. Principals (salaries in official capacity): Klebez $171,169 + $2,100 longevity; Nosal $143,639 + $3,675; Schessler $166,950 + $1,575. Library (README-sourced; the four library PDFs are UNEXTRACTED): FY2026 adopted budget $588,800, balanced, net $0 (Town Appropriation $584,300, 99.2%; State Aid $4,500); expenses Personnel $358,450 (61%), Library Operations $136,250, Property $81,900, Administration $12,200. Cash: Dec 2025 $426,502.18; May 2026 $355,041.96, of which $220,000 moved into CDs at 3.75%. FY2025 close: operating surplus $26,773.37; other income $21,835.59. The $650 Provident Bank reconciliation discrepancy is a LEAD, not a finding (Mar 2026 treasurer report describes it as an "as yet unresolved fraud situation with Provident Bank"); current status unknown. The ELEC donor cross-check is now COMPLETE for 2023–2025 (2026-09-18: 60 entities; 2025 all $0 except Mazzei $350; 2024 Disalvo $605, Weisman General $7,200, Weisman Primary $4,000, rest $0; 2023 Holly $500, Lynch Primary $7,100, Lynch General $22,231.70, rest $0; 56 itemized donors vs 2026 vendor list — no exact matches, one name-similarity lead "WARMINGTON, JACK" $100 vs vendor Robert Warmington, different first name, NOT a match; new lead: Boswell Engineering Inc $500 to Lynch's 2023 mayoral campaign — Boswell not on the 2026 vendor list, check via records whether Boswell appears in town vendor payments/contracts before drawing any inference) — still no donor finding. Financial-disclosure sweep now COMPLETE (2026-09-18): 2025: 23/23 fully read; 2024: 23/23 fully read; 2023: 25 statements fully read (every key-official statement across all three years). Documented official↔vendor relationships, all expected appointed-professional alignments: town attorneys disclosing "Dorsey & Semrau" income/business interest (2023–2025); municipal prosecutor Chris DiLorenzo disclosing "DiLorenzo & Rush" income and business interest (2023–2024; the firm holds the prosecutor appointment itself). All other disclosed entities (Coldstream Properties, Balan architecture LLC, Lynch CPA, CAPPS LLC, Bell Shivas & Bell PC, Carlson Law LLC, Schenck Price Smith & King, Progressive Casualty, Homecare Therapies, Yeshiva University, etc.) are screening leads only — zero matches against the contracts register or 2026 vendor list beyond the two expected relationships. No substantiated favoritism, conflict, or wrongdoing finding. Long-term: monitoring-plan.md holds the 30-item discrepancy watchlist, the release calendar, and a quarterly check procedure. Who holds spending authority is mapped in people-and-oversight.md (roster in schedules/people-roster.csv). Municipal five-year department trends are rebuilt (2026-09-18 rev pass 3: each year's own adopted budget used with transposition awareness; the 2022 and 2024 adopted budgets were located on boonton.org DocumentCenter > Finance); the FY2024 school ACFR and several older audits were not retrievable. "Not found online" is never treated as "withheld." See methods-and-limits.md.